Pink Green Blue

Scrivenshaft » C4

Back to the Scrivenshaft Challenge

Scrivenshaft Challenge Cycle IV – November 2005 : "Greeting the Season"

Cycle Dates: 30 October 2005 - 6 December 2005
Entries Submitted: 8
Winners Announced: 31 December 2005


The Prompt

The Premise:

“I’d just like to make it clear that I will be blaming all of this on you.”

The pair lay prone, sprawled across the arms of the sofa. Exhaustion was evident in each labored breath; a cat purred contentedly in the hollow between elbows, satisfied with the occasional stroke of one hand, nails bitten to nubs, fingers ink-stained and still sticky with caramel-coating.

They were sitting by what had been, only a few hours before, a roaring blaze. The speaker, face set with a wry smile to match the amused tone of the comment, looked about at what had been, once-upon-a-time, the epitome of a well-kept house, festively decorated. The other made a noise, and then opened their eyes, grimacing at the spatter of cranberry sauce still visible on the chandelier.

The room was cleaner than it once had been, but the tree in the corner was partially singed, the tree topper swaying drunkenly from the misshapen branches, still warbling the refrain from the night’s preferred carol. With the splotch on the lighting, one could discern traces of that tart fruit on several surfaces, and holiday greeting cards lay strewn about, several of which seemed charred and blackened; the acrid smell clung in the air, overpowering the pleasant cinnamon smoke swirling out of the cauldron on the table.

It had been nearly twenty minutes since either had made any significant movement.

But before long, that same hand shooed the cat off the cushion, and the pair summoned enough energy to rise from their stupors and return to work. They would be arriving at any moment, after all.


The Challenge

At the end of your entry, the above scene must make sense. Yes, all of it.

Your Limits

1. You may not quote any part of the above in your entry.
2. You will note that I have left out any names, genders, or time periods. Go crazy.
3. Time frame during the year is holiday-time (meaning December-ish).
4. You're not limited to HBP-canon this time, but we do ask you to keep all actions, pairings, uses of magic, and personalities realistic. No cross-overs, no extreme out-of-character portrayals of principal characters, etc.
5. Entries should not have a rating of more than R, and we would highly recommend that you keep your rating at PG-13 or below.
6. Entries should be no longer than 4000 words. Entries of no more than 500 words have an additional awards category, but entries of 4001 words will be disqualified.
7. Please stay with in the spirit of the prompt. Take advantage of its hints at personality, tone, and suspense. Exploit these to your advantage.
8. Just a thought: unique ideas (rational ones) are key. Clichés with mistletoe, while cute, may not sit well with judges after the 6th iteration.
9. Before submitting your entry, proofread it for any spelling, punctuation or grammatical mistakes. If you like, you may have the use of a beta reader prior to submission of entry, provided that the substance of the entry is your own effort.

The Award-Winners

Award-winning categories are explained on the main Scrivenshaft page.

This challenge brought several excellent entries, but three stood out in almost all judging surveys as exceptionally well-written and worthwhile. Each of these entries went beyond rewriting the prompt to give the scene depth and an individual flavor. Out of the eight entries, these three were voted as having the highest quality, and we are therefore happy to present them to you:

Raising The Bar: "Boiling the Tarts" by BeeDaily


Why we loved it:"Boiling the Tarts embodied the EXACT personalities I imagine Lily and James possessing, and these two characters interacted with all the stubbornness, cheekiness, and wit one would expect from canon descriptions of the two students while still at school. My ending comment, which can be found written on the story print-out, was 'Perfect.'" - anonymous "I highly recommend people to read it." - several judges

Cheering Charm: "Christmas Gifts" by Chelles


Why we loved it: "It might just be the romantic in me that’s rooting for this entry, but I loved the reconciliation and happiness that the ending promised." - anonymous "It contained some great insights into relationships - how petty things can get in the way, how forgiveness/reconciliation should factor in, and overall how love really can overcome big road-blocks IF YOU ALLOW IT." - anonymous

Outside the Box: "Three People, a House Elf, and a Cat" by ebonyquill


Why we loved it: "In most of the other stories, the cat was just mentioned in passing, but I liked how this author incorporated the cat into the story as a key character." - anonymous "I liked the way the storyline was set up. It added more interest to not be hearing the story directly. Clues to the overall plot were given in interesting ways. This one forced me to read between the lines a bit." - anonymous "This was pure fun to read!" - anonymous

The Challenge Entries

"Joyeux Noel" by LilyoftheValley23

"Midnight Christmas Cleaning" by sweetbananababe09
"Christmas to Remember by Anya
"Three People, a House Elf, and a Cat" by ebonyquill
"Boiling the Tarts" by BeeDaily

"Merry Thanks-east-mas!" by hell_penguin
"Christmas Gifts" by Chelles
"Christmas Pudding, and the Like" by mische

Back to the Scrivenshaft Challenge

Last updated by Permanent Accounteverblue3 the March 26th 2006, 1am.

Privacy Policy, Terms of Service. Coding created by Cine and constantly hacked by DNA since her disappearance. HARRY POTTER © and all related are the property of J.K. Rowling and various publishers, including but not limited to Bloomsbury Books, Scholastic Books, Raincoast Books, and Warner Bros. Entertainment. All works (stories and art) on unknowableroom.org are based on the original work with no copyright or trademark infringement intended. Unknowable Room is an unofficial, non-profit site not affiliated with afore mentioned entities. All works hosted on UR.org are property of their respected owner(s). No material may be reproduced from this site without expressed permission from its creator. UR.org takes no responsibility for views or opinions expressed by members. UR.org takes no responsibility for views or opinions expressed by members.