Reviews on "Four Minutes" by YKuang
Written by eleos on chapter #1.(September 12th 2011, 2am)
That was really sweet. *tear* Great one-shot, it was amazing.
Written by AnotherDreamer on chapter #1.(December 31st 2008, 6am)
I loved this. Absolutely.
Even before I got to the end and read the quote from the Sorcerer's Stone, I thought of Dumbledore's answer and the way Harry realized only a bit later that it was a bit of a personal question to ask what one saw in the mirror.
I liked the soft tone of this piece, this quiet feel, as if it were night. It was reinforced by the way they spoke quietly. And I liked that Ginny thought about how they were just pretending. Always just pretending. But her one childish comment about wishing, and Harry kisses her. He loves her. You showed us that. You showed us that not only is he choosing not to end his solitude, he is actively reinforcing it, forcing himself to be alone.
Written by Anonymous on chapter #1.(December 6th 2008, 9pm)
I, too, don't normally like Trio era fics. But this...was just so sweet. I really liked how well you captured the awkwardness and uncertainty between Harry and Ginny. Like there's so much to say and absolutely no way to say it. Well done!
Written by dancing_heron on chapter #1.(January 8th 2006, 7pm)
Absolutely lovely. I'm not sure if it's intended, but it does rather tie into "Two Conversations" (Which I also liked a lot...:]). And really, you never CAN have too many socks!
Written by eternalhope08 on chapter #1.(December 17th 2005, 9pm)
see, like most of the reviewers, I'm not a big fan of fanfiction writers trying to portray the trio...because normally, they can't do it. And i don't blame them at all...it's just that the trio belongs to JKR, and only to JKR. No one can quite capture their spirits as well as she can...because they're Hers. Esepcially Harry.
But you gave a damn good shot at it. I liked it a lot, for its poignant bittersweet taste that it leaves in your mouth. hopefully things look up for Ginny and Harry.
Do upload some L/J goodness, please. I LOVE them. hehehe, hopefully you "squeeed." if that's a word at all.
you're very talented--keep writing : ).
Written by BookwormRose on chapter #1.(December 5th 2005, 11pm)
That was perfect, in a very sad, bittersweet sort of way...it's very realistic and you remain very true to character...great fic
Written by prettyredbracelets on chapter #1.(November 1st 2005, 11pm)
Eeeeeeeeeee, sweet. :D Hee, it's super-sticky-fluffy-sweet and possibly the best He/She story ever.
Written by GirlInTheMirror on chapter #1.(November 1st 2005, 4am)
Very very very very very well done. Wow, so well done that you made me repeat a word. Need I say more?
Written by PotterChick958 on chapter #1.(October 29th 2005, 8pm)
I loved that. Oh, the things you can do in 4 minutes...But that was lovely. I loved how unsure Ginny was and how she wanted to simply pretend that she and Harry were just little kids again. And with your ending, I'm hopeful that Harry and Ginny will work it out and be together again.
Written by Anonymous on chapter #1.(October 27th 2005, 7am)
Hey I liked it alot. Nicely written and the feelings seemed so real as if I felt it myself. This is the first good one I've read about Harry and Ginny after HBP. You're an awesome writer. Well done.
Written by Anonymous on chapter #1.(October 25th 2005, 9pm)
I really like it, but it seems a bit incomplete! Please write more!!!!
Written by Anonymous on chapter #1.(October 25th 2005, 1am)
I'm normally not a big fan of trio era characters, but I always love reading your Ginny/Harry drabbles. I love the sock reference and I love the way that the minutes are kept careful track of, almost like there's a court reporter taking minutes. Well, that's what I thought anyway. XD
I loved this story!
Written by Anonymous on chapter #1.(October 23rd 2005, 9pm)
awww!!!! this was really really good!! kuds!
Written by thirty2flavors on chapter #1.(October 23rd 2005, 8pm)
I like this. It's cute. Typically I am not overly interested in trio-era characters, for... whatever reason, but this one caught my attention. It's neat what inspired you -- I remember that, ha -- and it's neat that you came up with this from that. Unfortunately, I do not seem to be up to writing a particularly useful or in depth review, because my brain is just not co-operating, but let's see... I definitely loved the sock reference. Really, that was my favorite part, I think. It was a neat thing to tie in, and it seems especially appropriate given the ending of HBP. Aw. I love Dumbledore.
I also quite liked the significance of the empty seats. It was very sad in its metaphorical way.
Very nice. Heeee.
Written by Anonymous on chapter #1.(October 23rd 2005, 7pm)
This was so beautiful. It was so soft, and heartwrenching. I loved it.